Using focus groups to plan culturally acceptable primary cervical cancer screening in Grenada, West Indies

Hyacinth-Purcell, Calisha; Sylvester-Gill, Jeannine; Sperr, Edwin; McPherson, Jane; Baldwin, Amy

Using focus groups to plan culturally acceptable primary cervical cancer screening in Grenada, West Indies

Cite

Hyacinth-Purcell, C., Sylvester-Gill, J., Sperr, E., McPherson, J., & Baldwin, A. (2023). Using focus groups to plan culturally acceptable primary cervical cancer screening in Grenada, West Indies [Journal articles]. https://iris.paho.org/handle/10665.2/57052

Files

v47e322023.pdf (318.77 KB)

Date

2023

ISSN

1680 5348

DOI

https://doi.org/10.26633/RPSP.2023.32

Authors

Hyacinth-Purcell, Calisha
Sylvester-Gill, Jeannine
Sperr, Edwin
McPherson, Jane
Baldwin, Amy

Description

[ABSTRACT]. Objective. To document Grenadian women’s knowledge about cervical cancer and human papillomavirus (HPV) infection, as well as their attitudes towards primary cervical cancer screening methods. Methods. In this qualitative study, we used focus groups in Grenada to gather information concerning women’s knowledge about, attitudes towards and perceptions of screening for cervical cancer and general knowledge about HPV. Ten focus groups comprising 73 participants representing 5 of the 6 parishes in Grenada were conducted with women aged 19–59. Participants were asked about pelvic exams, Pap smears, HPV, reasons for seeking or avoiding cervical cancer screening and how different modalities of testing might affect their decision-making. Responses were then coded and organized into common themes. Results. While many respondents had heard of HPV, far fewer knew about its causative role in cervical can- cer, how to prevent HPV infection or testing for the high-risk HPV types that cause almost all cases of cervical cancer. Many participants were aware that cervical cancer screening was beneficial, but numerous barriers to obtaining that screening were noted, including concerns about privacy and stigma, potential discomfort, and the cost and inconvenience involved. Conclusions. Our findings have implications for future cervical cancer screening efforts in Grenada. Central to these efforts should be a focus on educating Grenadians about the role of HPV infection in cervical cancer and the importance of early detection through screening. In addition, addressing issues of stigma and privacy are key to eliminating cervical cancer in Grenada.

[RESUMEN]. Objetivo. Documentar los conocimientos de las mujeres granadinas sobre el cáncer cervicouterino y la infección por el virus de los papilomas humanos (VPH), así como sus actitudes hacia los métodos primarios de detección del cáncer cervicouterino. Métodos. En este estudio cualitativo, se han empleado grupos focales en Granada para recopilar información sobre los conocimientos, las actitudes y las percepciones de las mujeres sobre la detección del cáncer cervicouterino y nociones generales sobre el VPH. Participaron 73 mujeres de 19 a 59 años de edad, representantes de 5 de las 6 parroquias de Granada. Se formaron diez grupos focales, a los que se les preguntó sobre los exámenes pélvicos, las pruebas de Papanicolaou, el VPH, las razones para buscar o evitar la detección del cáncer cervicouterino y cómo las diferentes modalidades de examen podrían afectar sus decisiones. Luego se codificaron las respuestas y se organizaron en temas comunes. Resultados. Si bien muchas participantes habían oído hablar del VPH, un número considerablemente menor conocía su relación causal con el cáncer cervicouterino, cómo prevenir la infección por VPH o los exámenes de detección de los tipos del VPH de alto riesgo que causan casi todos los casos de cáncer cervicouterino. Muchas participantes sabían que los exámenes de detección del cáncer de cuello uterino eran convenientes, pero mencionaron numerosos obstáculos para obtenerlos, como las preocupaciones sobre la privacidad y la estigmatización, posibles molestias, así como el costo y los inconvenientes relacionados. Conclusiones. Nuestros hallazgos tienen implicaciones para la futura labor de detección del cáncer cervicouterino en Granada. En esta labor debería ser esencial adoptar un enfoque dirigido a educar a las granadinas sobre la relación de la infección por VPH con el cáncer cervicouterino y la importancia de la detección temprana mediante exámenes. Además, combatir los problemas de estigmatización y privacidad es clave para eliminar el cáncer cervicouterino en Granada.

[RESUMO]. Objetivo. Documentar o conhecimento das mulheres de Granada sobre o câncer do colo do útero e a infecção por papilomavírus humano (HPV), bem como suas atitudes em relação aos métodos de rastreamento de câncer do colo do útero primário. Métodos. Neste estudo qualitativo, usamos grupos focais em Granada para coletar informações sobre conhecimentos, atitudes e percepções das mulheres sobre o rastreamento de câncer do colo do útero e conhecimentos gerais sobre HPV. Foram conduzidos dez grupos focais, incluindo 73 participantes e representando 5 das 6 paróquias de Granada, com mulheres de 19 a 59 anos de idade. As participantes responderam perguntas sobre exames ginecológicos, Papanicolau, HPV, razões para procurar ou evitar o rastreamento de câncer do colo do útero e como diferentes modalidades de testes podem afetar sua tomada de decisão. As respostas foram codificadas e organizadas por temas comuns. Resultados. Muitas participantes já tinham ouvido falar do HPV, mas um número muito menor conhecia sua relação causal com o câncer do colo do útero, formas de prevenir a infecção por HPV ou os testes para os tipos de HPV de alto risco, que causam quase todos os casos de câncer do colo do útero. Muitas participantes sabiam que o rastreamento de câncer do colo do útero era benéfico, mas várias barreiras para o rastreamento foram indicadas, incluindo preocupações relacionadas à privacidade e ao estigma, o potencial desconforto e o custo e inconveniência envolvidos. Conclusões. Nossos achados têm implicações para as futuras iniciativas de rastreamento de câncer do colo do útero em Granada. Essas iniciativas devem se focar em educar a população de Granada sobre o papel da infecção por HPV no câncer do colo do útero e a importância da detecção precoce por meio do rastreamento. Além disso, é fundamental abordar questões de estigma e privacidade para eliminar o câncer do colo do útero em Granada.

Pages

32

Volume

47

Citation

Hyacinth-Purcell C, Sylvester-Gill J, Sperr E, McPherson J, Baldwin A. Using focus groups to plan culturally acceptable primary cervical cancer screening in Grenada, West Indies. Rev Panam Salud Publica. 2023;47:e32. https://doi.org/10.26633/RPSP.2023.32

Collections

Pan American Journal of Public Health

License

cbn

Full item page

Related items

Showing items related by metadata.

Investigating under-reported human papillomavirus genotypes in Grenadian women through self-sampling for cervical cancer screening
(2024) McGill, Frances; Fields, Paul J.; Bahadoor-Yetman, Aví; Manglardi, Erin Salter; Bailey, Ronelle; Padala, Kritika; et.al
[ABSTRACT]. Objective. To compare the adequacy, agreement, and acceptability of Papanicolaou testing (cytology) for cervical cancer screening using self-collected samples compared to physician-collected samples in Grenada in the Caribbean. Furthermore, the study identifies the human papillomavirus (HPV) genotypes present among asymptomatic women testing positive for HPV, the etiologic cause of cervical cancer. Methods. Participants were divided into two groups and two cervical samples were collected from the women in each group: a self-collected sample and a physician-collected sample. Cervical specimens were tested for cytology and HPV. HPV genotyping was performed on positive specimens. Results. Self-collected samples were adequate and in agreement with physician-collected samples, showing no difference between the two sampling methods. Oncogenic high-risk HPV genotypes were identified in cervical samples which were positive for atypical squamous cells and low-grade squamous intraepithelial lesions. The high-risk HPV genotypes found, notably HPV 45 and 53, differed from those most commonly reported. Although the commonly reported high-risk genotypes HPV 16 and 18 were found, so were 31, 33, 35, 52, 66, 68, and 82. Conclusions. Using self-collection facilitated the discovery of unexpected HPV genotypes among asymptomatic women in Grenada. These findings add new information to the literature regarding cervical cancer and neoplasia screening and HPV genotypes in the Caribbean. This genotype information may impact surveillance of women with low-grade lesions, HPV vaccine selection, and possibly further vaccine research. Research regarding HPV in Caribbean pathology samples of cervical neoplasia and cancer is needed.
Systematic literature review of pri- mary and secondary cervical cancer prevention programs in South America
(2023) Gomes, Maria Luziene de Sousa; Moura, Nádya dos Santos; Magalhães, Letícia de Carvalho; Silva, Roger Rodrigues da; Silva, Bárbara Gomes Santos; Rodrigues, Ivana Rios; Sales, Luiz Belino Ferreira; Oriá, Mônica Oliveira Batista
[ABSTRACT]. Objective. To identify the 2022 recommendations made by ministries of health in the 13 countries and areas of South America for human papillomavirus (HPV) vaccination and cervical cancer screening. Methods. A systematic review of scientific literature and official documents was conducted between July 7 and October 17, 2022. The review included an initial search on official websites (e.g. ministries of health, national cancer institutes and health departments) of South American countries to identify current guidelines or recommendations for HPV vaccination and cervical cancer screening. Results. Recommendations for HPV vaccination were found for 11 countries, with the exceptions of French Guiana and the Bolivarian Republic of Venezuela. Recommendations were found for cervical cancer screening in official documents from 11 countries, with the exceptions of the Bolivarian Republic of Venezuela, where one article was found that was not an official recommendation, and Suriname, for which no documents were found on websites or in other publications. A total of 12 countries use cytology to screen for cervical cancer. Four countries (Bolivia [Plurinational State of], Colombia, Guyana and Peru) use visual inspection with acetic acid and the screen-and-treat strategy. Six countries (Argentina, Chile, Colombia, Ecuador, Paraguay and Peru) are transitioning from cytology to HPV testing. Conclusions. No documents were found about a national HPV vaccination program in French Guiana and Venezuela, and no official guidelines for cervical cancer screening were found for Suriname and Venezuela; thus, it will be difficult to eliminate this public health problem in these countries. Countries in South America must update their guidelines for HPV vaccination and cervical cancer screening as new evidence emerges. Official websites with information about HPV vaccination and cervical cancer screening are important sources that can be accessed by health professionals and the population.
Prevalence of cervical cancer and associated mortality in Grenada, 2000–2010
(2016) Bahadoor-Yetman, A.; Riley, L.; Gibbons, A.; Fields, P. J.; Mapp-Alexander, V.
Objective. To assess cervical cancer prevalence and associated mortality in Grenada, West Indies during 2000–2010. Methods. Records of visits to hospital and clinical facilities were obtained from the histopathology laboratory of the Grenada General Hospital. Records were de-identified and electronically compiled. Cervical cancer prevalence was assessed via cross-sectional analysis of this secondary data. Of a total 12 012 records, 2 527 were selected for analysis using sampling without replacement. Cases were matched to corresponding patient data from death registries, where possible, and used to calculate associated mortality rates. Results. The observed prevalence of cervical cancer was 52.4 per 100 000 women (ages 15 and above). The highest rates of cervical cancer occurred in the 35–44 age group, with the second highest among 45–64-year-olds. A total of 65 deaths were attributable to cervical cancer during 2000–2010, more than 50% of which were among women > 65 years old. The observed mortality rate was 16.7 per 100 000, almost twice the rate estimated by WHO for the region. Conclusions. This study demonstrates the need for a comprehensive cervical cancer-screening program in Grenada. Results should contribute to informing future studies on how to appropriately generate and execute public health policy for education, screening, prevention, and control of cervical cancer in Grenada.
High frequency of HPV high-risk preventable genotypes in Ecuadorian women with invasive cervical cancer
(2024-12-04) García Muentes, Gustavo David; Abdul Latif, Fadi; Beltrán Rodríguez, Claudia Catalina; Medina González, Sebastián; Ruiz Cabezas, Juan Carlos
[ABSTRACT]. Objective. To determine the distribution of human papillomavirus (HPV) genotypes in invasive cervical cancer samples from Ecuadorian women who attended the Cancer Institute (Sociedad de Lucha Contra el Cáncer – SOLCA). Methods. Archived formalin-fixed paraffin-embedded (FFPE) cervical cancer tissue samples collected during 2017–2021 were deparaffinized, and nucleic acid extraction and purification was performed using silica columns. The obtained nucleic acids were analyzed using INNO-LiPA® HPV Genotyping Extra II per the manufacturer’s specifications. Data were retrieved from records, and HPV genotypes were determined from the FFPE samples. Results. The study included samples from 190 women diagnosed with invasive cervical cancer, with a median age of 52.78 years. Squamous cell carcinoma accounted for 78.94% of the cases, while 21.05% had adenocarcinoma. Among the 190 samples, 80.53% tested positive for HPV DNA, while 19.47% were negative. The most common genotypes detected were HPV 16 (64.05%), 18 (16.99%), and 58 (6.54%). HPV infection frequency was higher in samples from patients with elementary level education (p < 0.05). Conclusions. This study provides valuable insights into the distribution of HPV genotypes in invasive cervical cancer samples from Ecuadorian women. The results indicate an elevated presence of HPV 16, HPV 18, and HPV 58, which are vaccine-preventable genotypes.
Geographical inequities in cervical cancer screening coverage in Bolivia: a spatial nationwide ecological study
(2025-05-27) Huanca Challgua, Carla; Linander, Ida; Goicolea, Isabel; Eid Rodriguez, Daniel; Fonseca-Rodríguez, Osvaldo
[ABSTRACT]. Objectives. To estimate cervical cancer screening (CCS) coverage rates and assess the spatial distribution and clustering between departments and municipalities in Bolivia. Methods. Standardized CCS coverage rates were calculated using the direct standardization method. The global Moran’s I test was used to investigate the existence of spatial autocorrelation of CCS coverage, and the Getis-Ord Gi* was used to identify the spatial clustering of municipalities with high (hot spot) or low (cold spot) coverage. Results. Overall coverage was low. Around 14% of women aged 20–69 years were screened in Bolivia in 2022. Large geographical inequities in CCS coverage rates were identified both between departments and between municipalities. At the municipal level, CCS showed large differences, ranging from 59% to below 1%. Hot spots were identified in northwestern and southeastern Bolivia; specifically, in Pando, Chuquisaca, and Tarija departments. Cold spots were identified in Beni and Santa Cruz departments. Conclusions. Bolivia is still a long way from achieving the World Health Organization target of 70% screening coverage. The present results indicate where the screening program must be reinforced to improve the responsiveness of Bolivia’s health system to women’s reproductive health needs.